A killer question by a genius of a theist
in Religion

@ethang5

>You're on vacay in another country. While walking in the wilderness you crest a ridge and see in the distance 3 men holding down a squirming screaming woman and one of the men is holding a knife and is trying to cut her neck.

Are the 3 men being immoral?

We do not have enough information to tell.

Here is info you need.
1. Intent
a. The men could be a field medical team trying to save the woman's life.
b. The men could be a band of rapists trying to kill the woman they just raped.

2. Relationship
a. The men and the woman could be a group of actors filming a violent scene.
b. The men could be complete strangers to the woman.

3. Authority
a. The men could be police officers trying to get detonator the woman has in her mouth.
b. The men could be robbers trying to get the diamond ring the woman has in her mouth.

This is why you can't just stupidly call an act immoral when you do not know the details.


Are the 3 men being immoral?

We do not have enough information to tell